Table 1

Quantitative risk estimates for a health impact assessment model of urban developments

Environmental factorsHealth effects for which quantitative risk estimates could be or have been derived given the current evidence base
AirAcute effects on mortality and hospital admissions, and long term effects on mortality and chronic diseases exist24,25
ChemicalsLifetime cancer risk estimates for changes in chemical carcinogen concentrations exist23
NoiseCommunity noise is considered a possible contributor to heart disease,28 but the noise exposed population and multiple sources of noise (demolition, construction, operation and traffic) must be considered. The physical health effects from short-term noise exposure are unclear
Traffic (trauma/exercise)Accident statistics are available for local areas, although a proportion of injured people are not locally resident. Modal shifts (between vehicle and walking or cycling) are not usually assessed within environmental statements, so these health effects are difficult to quantify30
Water (tap)See chemicals; infections short-term. Difficult to estimate population exposed
AgricultureNot usually relevant to urban developments
Forestry (fire)Not usually relevant to urban developments
ClimateEffects very long-term and international. Small contribution from an individual development to the overall effect43
Hazardous incidentsNot included in the model
Community severanceEffects on physical health are not quantified
Changes in employmentComplex effects, both negative and positive.44 Difficult to quantify the exposed population
Changes in health and welfare servicesThe health impacts of health services at national level have been estimated.45 Environmental statements usually only describe changes in provision
Sociocultural effectsRelation to health not quantified46
Recreation (leisure)Changes in population exercise are not usually quantified in environmental statements47